This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.
- Home
- Research
Research
We carry out scenario analysis and research to examine and understand how potential changes to supply and demand will impact the future of fossil fuel-exposed companies and projects. This analysis helps the investment community better understand the financial implications of tackling climate change
Popular Searches
Popular Reports



Absolute Impact 2023: Progress on oil and gas...



Kazakhstan Energy Transition


Loading the DICE Against Pensions


There Will Be Blood: Decommissioning California’s...


Stranded Strategies
Oil and Gas company narratives about the future of fossil fuels remain positive, their bank accounts are full. But their strategies show...

Avoiding Stranded Assets: risk aversion in oil development
Carbon Tracker has long warned of the risk of investing in future stranded assets; i.e., assets that fail to generate the returns expected...

Are we winning?
To paraphrase the Charles Dickens classic, A Tale of Two Cities: in 2023 in terms of energy, we are in the best of times, and in the worst...

Is the Chevron Deference about to be Deferred?
Recently, the US Supreme Court has not shied away from issuing precedent-setting decisions. Next year, that trend may continue when they...

The Climate Risk Delusion: Under-pricing climate risk contributes to climate change itself, and puts global pension wealth in peril
Our July research has been focussed on a major new report – Loading the DICE Against Pensions, written for Carbon Tracker by Professor...

The energy transition is already here – and becoming widely distributed
William Gibson is often quoted with the line “The future is already here — it's just not very evenly distributed.” It has become...Popular Reads
Absolute Impact 2023: Progress on oil and gas emissions targets has stalled
We carry out scenario analysis and research to examine and understand how potential changes to supply and...
Read MoreKazakhstan Energy Transition
We carry out scenario analysis and research to examine and understand how potential changes to supply and...
Read MoreIt’s been remarked on already, but let’s repeat it: this autumn could define how the international community responds to...
Read MoreNet Zero has become an energy transition delay tactic, driven by incumbents, but it is unlikely to work - as we detail in this...
Read MoreThe recent Environmental Audit Committee’s (EAC) Finance and Net Zero Inquiry, gives us an opportunity to look how...
Read MoreStanding at the crossroads: Colorado Commissioners facing difficult...
Climate risk disclosure Blog April 2023As the Colorado Oil and Gas Conservation Commission (COGCC) evaluates operator bonding proposals, and goes through hearings on...
Read MoreWith UK and European leaders continuing to ponder the long-term future of power market design, common themes continue to arise...
Read MoreMajor oil and gas companies still have choices about how to minimise the risk of having stranded assets, for now. Early in...
Read MoreWith oil and gas firms announcing executive pay packages, some have come under fire for the bumper payouts awarded to their top...
Read MoreIn early 2022, Colorado overhauled its financial assurance rules for oil and gas companies in a rulemaking mandated by SB...
Read MoreThere must have been a time in the 1920s some 20 years after the introduction of the Model T Ford in the United States, and with...
Read MoreAt more than 300 pages, there is much to absorb in Chris Skidmore MP’s Net-Zero Review for the British government – and to...
Read MoreLast month, President Biden marked his second year in office. As a candidate, he often discussed the need to take on climate...
Read MoreDownload Infographic Here The energy transition may well be determined by the phenomenon of S-curves. This is because the future...
Read MoreThis article was first published by Brink News, with thanks to Thomas Carver. The shift away from a carbon-based economy risks...
Read MoreOne in three UK car sales may be fully electric by end ‘23 as S-Curve...
Automotive Blog January 2023Blog Series: The UK’s adoption of BEVs – in 2016 UK BEV car sales (all electric) were a mere one in a 100, and derided. By...
Read MoreCarbon Tracker Research in an Energy Transition Context: October through November 2022 COP27 Special Report: African...
Read MoreThe consensus about COP27 was one of disappointment. The sense of anti-climax has thrown into even sharper focus the huge...
Read MoreCommentators like to say that midterm elections are a referendum on the party in power. So, what do these results mean for...
Read MoreDespite heavy restrictions and security at the Egypt conference, a record number of Civil Society organisations and activists...
Read MoreOn Monday 24th October, Mark Carney (the UN Special Envoy for Climate Action and Finance at United Nations and Co-Chair of the...
Read MoreCompared with the somewhat more benign backdrop to COP26 and Glasgow 12 months ago, the political conditions underpinning COP27...
Read MoreStarting in a fortnight will be one of the most crucial climate conferences of the year, COP27. Hosted this year in Egypt, the...
Read MoreThis year has seen the fundamental dynamics of global energy markets turned completely on their head. A potent cocktail of...
Read MoreThe UK’s energy security strategy is back at the forefront of political debate. As the government looks to show leadership...
Read MoreSummer 2022 has been a rollercoaster for climate advocates in America. On June 30, the US Supreme Court ruled, in West...
Read MoreBut it might just save the world North American oil and gas companies are going big on carbon capture, utilisation, and...
Read MoreIn June, Saudi Aramco published its first ever Sustainability Report, containing details of its "net zero by 2050” target and...
Read MoreOn June 30, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that the EPA does not have authority, under the Clean Air Act, to set up an emissions...
Read More*This blog is written by Dwayne Purvis for Carbon Tracker* The dynamics of unfunded plugging liabilities have changed so...
Read MoreNone of the CA100+ focus companies within upstream oil & gas production or coal & gas-powered electricity generation have...
Read MoreRussia’s unprovoked invasion of Ukraine has created terrible consequences for those living inside Ukraine, but at the same time...
Read MoreOut of the frying pan and into the fire: the heat is building on climate...
Energy transition Blog February 2022As temperatures accelerate towards 1.5˚C, near-term actions that limit global warming would reduce losses and damages related to...
Read MoreToday the Supreme Court hears oral arguments in the case of West Virginia v. EPA. The case centers on the EPA’s ability to...
Read MoreWith respect to asset retirement obligations in the oil patch, every regulator has to answer three questions: How do you...
Read MoreWhy Jordan Peterson Should Think Again on the Energy Transition
Energy transition Blog February 2022On a recent episode of Joe Rogan’s controversial and highly influential podcast, Canadian psychology professor and best-selling...
Read MoreLate last month ExxonMobil launched its Advancing Climate Solutions – 2022 Progress Report,[1] which describes how it is...
Read MoreOpinion: Liberalisation and decarbonisation are a recipe for volatility
Energy transition Guest Blog February 2022Market-based pricing for gas saved EU consumers billions – until this winter's energy crunch came along. Europe’s exposure to...
Read MoreAs a candidate President Biden spoke of the need to act on climate change and said, “it requires action, not denial…...
Read MoreTo keep 1.5°C alive, immediate action on methane emissions is required from the oil and gas industry, with significant impact...
Read More2021 Wrapped Up Here is an infographic of the key events that took place at Carbon Tracker and in the climate space in...
Read MoreWe welcome the recent announcement that South Africa has struck a deal to access concessional financing of $8.5bn over the next...
Read MoreRecently I wrote about how the Biden Administration’s efforts to fight climate change could be sailing into rough waters after...
Read MoreIn January, the Colorado Oil and Gas Conservation Commission (COGCC) will vote on the new financial assurance rules for Colorado,...
Read MoreRight now, global energy commodity prices remain close to long-term highs despite recent declines. But short-term strength in...
Read MoreAfter months of legislative negotiations, the $1.2 trillion Infrastructure bill made it through Congress and was signed by...
Read MoreThe Chinese government has been sending mixed messages on its long-term climate ambitions once again On the one hand, an...
Read MoreRepsol has seemingly upped its emissions cutting game In early October, responding to shareholder pressure, Repsol announced a...
Read MoreThere is a paradox at the heart of expertise: those who have accumulated the most authority in an industry are often those least...
Read MoreColorado’s ineffective financial assurance and well plugging rules have allowed the growth of a large portfolio of marginal and...
Read MoreThe world has changed a lot since Paris; so too should the logic of climate mitigation. Mitigating climate change is no longer...
Read MoreOn Monday 9th August, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) delivered a climate report warning of ‘code red for...
Read MoreIn less than 100 days COP26 will start. Many agree that this year’s conference is being held at a critical moment. To...
Read MoreThe election of President Joe Biden brought a seismic shift in U.S. government policy toward climate change. In addition to...
Read MoreEnding the use of coal for power generation in South Korea by 2028 is not only possible but also the most economical option in...
Read MoreThe IEA’s latest piece on minerals[1] critical to the energy transition gives a rather pessimistic spin to what was some very...
Read MoreIn the run up to COP 26 many oil and gas companies have announced ‘net-zero by 2050’ targets. However, very few companies...
Read MoreShell and Eni’s recent strategy updates have highlighted a key emerging point in the debate on oil and gas companies’...
Read MoreAs the Colorado Oil and Gas Conservation Commission (COGCC) weighs competing demands of protecting the state finances and...
Read MoreThere’s a quip about lawyers that goes 99% of attorneys give the rest a bad name. The same can be said about oil producers...
Read More“Having looked to government for bread, on the first scarcity they will turn and bite the hand that fed them.” Edmund...
Read More2020 was a tough year for big oil. Short-term demand was hammered by the impacts of Covid-19, while the ever-growing...
Read MoreWhen it comes to oilfield plugging obligations, industry voices contend that industry has the problem in hand.[1] And where it...
Read MoreEmissions trajectories continue to bend lower Last month, both Shell and Eni revised their scope 3 emissions plans, updating...
Read MoreAs Colorado considers improvements to its oil and gas regulations, some will undoubtedly point to its idle well program as a...
Read MoreThis weekend marks the end of the first month of the Biden Presidency. In the weeks since the inauguration we have seen a wave...
Read MoreColorado drillers pay pennies on the dollar to plug oil wells
Climate risk disclosure Blog February 2021The Colorado Oil & Gas Compact Commission (COGCC) is considering improvements to its oil and gas bonding regime. These...
Read MoreTo ensure companies meet their obligations to plug oil and gas wells and reclaim drilling sites, Colorado regulations require oil...
Read MoreKingsmill Bond on BBC News talking Joe Biden’s Presidency & the...
Energy transition Blog January 2021Carbon Tracker's New Energy Strategist Kingsmill Bond argues the election of Joe Biden on a ticket to restore America's climate...
Read More2021 is a year of opportunity; one of resetting, reshaping and a chance to remove distortions that hinder an orderly energy...
Read MoreAmid rising tension the final votes of the 2020 US election were cast last week. By electing Democrats Raphael Warnock and John...
Read MoreCarbon Tracker's Christmas Cracker had a makeover in 2020. This infographic originally went out in our December newsletter,...
Read MoreFor the past two years, the Green New Deal (GND) has driven the conversation about how to address climate change. It has been the...
Read More2020 has, to put it mildly, been full of surprises. Oil and gas companies, long predictable and averse to change, have even...
Read MoreThe oil and gas industry, like many other commodity industries, has long been characterised by volatility, instability and...
Read MoreGuest post by Carbon Tracker advisory board member Nick Robins - reposted with permission from the author If there is one...
Read MoreThe exit of Trump removes the greatest impediment to the energy transition, and will unleash a great era of creativity and...
Read MoreExplorers use maps intensively, but they take the information recorded in the charts they use with a few grains of salt, knowing...
Read MoreA key tipping point was reached in 2019. Global demand for fossil fuels peaked and is unlikely ever to recover to its pre-crisis...
Read MoreGiven the 24 hour news cycle around the US Congressional and Presidential Election, it would be easy to focus only on what...
Read MoreThe Texas-based company Vistra recently announced that they will close six coal power plants and cut their coal generating...
Read MoreDuring her presidential campaign announcement, Senator Amy Klobuchar declared that on her first day in office she would take the...
Read More"Nobody move! I have a hostage. If anyone follows us, I'll kill myself and then her." Roy Miller, Knight and Day A classic...
Read MoreAs part of a UK government-funded project to support the Philippines power sector stakeholders navigate the shifts, risks and...
Read MorePassing transformative climate change legislation through the U.S. Congress will be one of the major legislative battles of this...
Read MoreOne of the world’s leading energy forecasters released a report this morning arguing that 2019 was the peak of the fossil fuel...
Read More"Oil and gas companies are hurtling toward bankruptcy, raising fears that wells will be left leaking planet-warming pollutants,...
Read MoreBP has elaborated on its strategy to deliver net zero – cutting oil and gas production by “at least” 40% by...
Read MoreLast Call – States’ final chance to avoid the clean-up tab for big...
Climate risk disclosure Blog July 2020The coronavirus pandemic has caused a sharp decline in oil demand, putting intense pressure on oil companies with large...
Read MoreThe Earth's temperatures continue to rise causing catastrophic climate change. The risks of climate change are having major...
Read MoreKey findings: Our research shows that UK Export Finance supports upstream oil projects that seem very likely to become...
Read MoreThis blog was originally posted here on 26 May 2020. It is reprinted with permission. The world of Environmental, Social and...
Read MoreThe sudden economic downturn brought on by the Coronavirus threatens to cripple the finances of U.S state governments. The...
Read MoreThe COVID-19 pandemic shut economies, disrupted established global production chains and pressed an indefinite pause on the...
Read MoreAt the end of February, Italian oil major Eni announced new carbon emissions reduction plans. While not aiming for net zero...
Read MoreIn ancient Greek theatre, deus ex machina (“god from the machine”) is when a seemingly intractable plot issue is...
Read MoreThis blog updates our 2018 note Carbon Budgets Explained. Carbon budgets – the amount of carbon dioxide emissions permitted...
Read MoreThe Covid-19 crisis is showing up the oil and gas industry’s exposure to the threat of falling demand, a forewarning of what...
Read MoreThe IEA on Thursday[1] released some eye-watering projections for energy demand declines in 2020 in the light of the Covid19...
Read MoreOne of last year’s key developments relating to climate change risks was a handful of fossil fuel producers agreeing to show...
Read MoreWritten by: Greg Rogers, Theron Horton, Rob Schuwerk Is the goal to get out all of the oil, or get out of the retirement...
Read MoreThe arms race in setting carbon emissions targets is such that Shell, once one of the industry leaders when it announced its...
Read MoreAt this time of crisis, the immediate issue is to solve the health and economic emergencies, and we salute the heroes of the...
Read MoreI was sitting in a hot tub in Leningrad in the summer of 1990 when I realised the Soviet Union would fall. There were five of...
Read MoreCOVID-19 is crippling economies and creating turmoil in financial markets. This note gives our outlook for coal generation in...
Read MoreCOVID-19 continues to shake the global economy, and energy markets are no exception. Oil in particular finds itself caught...
Read MoreThe piece originally was posted to the World Economic Forum website on March 18, 2020. The impact of China's previous...
Read MoreThe piece originally was posted to LGIM Future World Blog on February 26, 2020. It is reprinted with permission. By Nick...
Read MoreAmid ever-increasing concerns over climate risks, BP is the latest European oil and gas company to announce a climate goal with...
Read MoreThe purpose of this note is to: Address RWE’s response to our recent report Apocoalypse Now, by acknowledging that, per...
Read MoreCoal power is losing its economic footing. As detailed in Figure 1, according to Carbon Tracker analysis, which is based on...
Read MoreRepsol has just announced a shift in strategic direction – to become a net zero emissions company by 2050. This move extends...
Read MoreEconomist Ann Pettifor is one of several leading thinkers publishing books on the Green New Deal (GND) this year. However unlike...
Read MoreOnce upon a time – the 1990s if you are interested -- there was a wondrous oil company called Exxon. It was run by a clever...
Read MoreSubmission to Treasury Committee on Green Finance & Decarbonisation...
Climate risk disclosure Blog September 2019Carbon Tracker's Mike Knight submitted evidence to the Treasury Select Committee inquiry into the decarbonisation of the UK...
Read MoreThe Amazon is burning, Greenland is melting, the US is rolling back environmental protections, and the energy sector consensus is...
Read MoreAt Carbon Tracker - our research focus is the impact of climate change on financial markets. Our global coal report, Powering...
Read MoreLast week Carbon Tracker’s power & utilities team was in Manila to attend the launch of a UK government-funded project to...
Read MoreDuring the inaugural London Climate Action Week - Carbon Tracker co-hosted the Climate Risk and the Capital Domino Effect event...
Read MoreRecently Carbon Tracker’s power and utilities team travelled to Vietnam to market our latest analyst note, Here Comes the Sun...
Read More14 June | The Vatican Mary Robinson served as president of Ireland from 1990 to 1997, and as UN High Commissioner for Human...
Read MoreThe following piece originally was posted to Oilprice.com on March 3, 2019. It is reprinted with permission. Investors are...
Read MoreThe UK Climate Change Committee (CCC) has reported on its recommended targets for the UK to reduce its greenhouse gas emissions...
Read MoreConocoPhillips: Concerned on Capex, Cagey on the Dwindling Carbon Budget
Climate risk disclosure Blog March 2019ConocoPhillips’ February 2019 climate report lays out a thoughtful approach to governing climate risk. It addresses...
Read MoreWhy shareholders should rethink executive reward For much of the early part of this century, the oil and gas industry was in...
Read MoreThe missing link – bridging the gap between emission targets and fossil...
Climate risk disclosure Blog February 2019To manage against the goals of the Paris Agreement, oil companies like Chevron must factor scope 3 emissions into their capital...
Read MoreBP and Glencore announce plans to link fossil fuel investments to Paris Agreement goals 2019 is shaping up to be the year in...
Read MoreBy Anthony Hobley Attending Davos for the World Economic Forum (WEF) Annual Meeting is like being thrown into the centre of...
Read MoreArriving into Katowice Poland, host city for COP24, you were immediately struck by the obvious conflict at the heart of the UN...
Read MoreMyths of the Energy Transition – Don’t Let Stranded Economic Thinking...
Energy transition Blog December 2018In the 2014 film Merchants of Doubt a small group of well funded lobbyists cast doubts over the science linking tobacco to lung...
Read MoreAdding a Green Economy to a Brown Economy Does Not Equal Success.
Energy transition Blog November 2018Our Take on OECD Green Finance 2018 Over 2 days in Paris, 13-14 November business leaders, Government policy makers, NGOs and...
Read MoreThis blog originally appeared on the IEEFA website By Tom Sanzillo, Kathy Hipple and Clark Williams-Derry Invest in the...
Read MoreBy Paul Spedding BP chief executive Bob Dudley is at risk of being branded an altruist if his “Oil and Money” speech to...
Read MoreCarbon capture and storage, or CCS, refers to technologies that allow us to capture CO2 at the source of its production and...
Read MoreOne of the questions we are most frequently asked by investors is – how can we tell if a company is “Paris compliant”? This...
Read MoreIn the nexus of climate change and financial markets, disclosure is the flavour of the day. Carbon Tracker recently analysed...
Read MoreGuest Blog from Greg Rogers, Co-founder, Eratosthenes LLC In a classic scene from the 1976 American comedy, The Gumball Rally,...
Read MoreOne year ago we posted here comes the sun – a blog which found the lowest solar bid of 2017 could be less than the cash cost of...
Read MoreSeveral financial institutions have recently announced they will stop funding new coal power projects, with HSBC being the...
Read MoreWell Cooked? EOG Resources drops resolution on GHG emissions
Climate risk disclosure Blog April 2018An SEC decision allowed EOG Resources to exclude a shareholder resolution on GHG emissions A recent SEC decision allowing EOG...
Read MoreSummary Occidental neglects demand fundamentals in its 2°C analysis and opts for the foregone conclusion of a test against...
Read MoreChevron’s recent climate change disclosures become the first to reach down to the asset level, but remain light on useful...
Read MoreExxonMobil's Energy and Carbon Summary is a step in the right direction, but lacks clarity across a number of...
Read MoreA PDF version of this paper is available here. An updated version of this note is available now in Carbon Budgets: Where are...
Read MoreIf you read just one thing this year…… first, it’s December! What took you so long?......second, make it this. Much...
Read MoreA Time Machine for Climate Risk: bringing the future forward with 2˚C...
Climate risk disclosure Blog November 2017See here for a downloadable version of this blog. “Breaking the Tragedy of the Horizon” It has been two years since the...
Read MoreState of the transition: The roulette wheels of Las Vegas land on green
Energy transition Blog September 2017What have Las Vegas casinos got in common with tackling climate change and transitioning to a low carbon economy? More than you...
Read MoreDoes the oil major’s 2017 Energy Perspectives mark new thinking for the company? On June 8th, Statoil published the 2017...
Read MoreIndustry opposes enhanced climate risk disclosure, concerned it will move...
Climate risk disclosure Blog May 2017Robert Shuwerk responds to industry opposition to the TCFD recommendations. The Financial Stability Board’s task force on...
Read MoreGlencore released a report last week ahead of its Annual General Meeting aimed at assessing the long-term implications of climate...
Read MoreCost reductions of India’s solar revolution should serve as a warning to coal investors This week solar PV prices in India...
Read MoreFormer UN climate change chief Christiana Figueres brings new urgency to the global climate conversation with a campaign to...
Read MoreUnexpectedly, the oil and gas love-in that is CERAWeek saw the latest round of climate risk disclosure emerging from the oil...
Read MoreFinancial Stability Board talks of climate change in a language investors...
Climate risk disclosure Blog January 2017Carbon Tracker's Rob Schuwerk explains why the FSB's climate risk recommendations are an important step towards helping financial...
Read MoreThe 12 Days of Carbon Tracker Well…that was different. 2016 has been quite the year of change. A year of political events that...
Read MoreState of The Transition, November 2016: Steps forward continue to...
Energy transition Guest Blog December 2016Guest post by Jeremy Leggett, Non-executive chairman of Carbon Tracker The global energy transition remains in...
Read MoreLatest IEA Outlook outlines an accelerated low-carbon transition
Energy transition Blog November 2016WEO 2016 also warns of disjointed scenario if energy transition is delayed. Scenarios are not forecasts The scenarios produced...
Read MoreGuest post by Kingsmill Bond, new energy analyst at Trusted Sources (research & consultancy) The orthodox view is that...
Read MoreEven if oil prices rise in the aftermath of the OPEC agreement on cutting production, the oil industry should be wary of...
Read MoreCarbon Tracker’s reports and blogs are available in seven different languages: Arabic...
Read MoreA series of recent Forbes articles intend to cast doubt on the relevance of stranded asset risks to investors. Mark Fulton,...
Read MoreIn 2016, the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia has a major opportunity to develop a new industry, an opportunity that became something of...
Read MoreThe recent shift in China’s economy has been one of dramatic speed and scale. The first decade of the 2000s saw China’s...
Read MoreBy Paul Spedding, Former Global Co-Head of Oil And Gas Research at HSBC and Advisor to Carbon Tracker. First appeared on...
Read MoreJust because one of Britain's best loved vehicles rolled off the production line for the last time last week doesn't...
Read MoreShelagh Whitley and Mark Fulton President Obama’s rejection of the Keystone XL pipeline last November signalled a landmark...
Read MoreStranded Assets a Response: Myth or Reality? Late last year respected British economist Dieter Helm dismissed the concept of...
Read MoreIs Royal Dutch Shell, one of the world’s biggest oil and gas companies, really turning its back on fossil fuels? Not only has...
Read More“First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win.” Mahatma Gandhi I recently attended a...
Read MoreFirst appeared in BusinessGreen Global coal is on the ropes. Prices of thermal coal have collapsed as demand evaporates;...
Read MoreThis guest post by Paul Gilding, an independent writer, corporate advisor and advocate for action on climate change and...
Read MoreFirst appeared in BusinessGreen Will the United Nations Climate Change Conference (COP 21) in Paris later this year be a...
Read MorePetrobras’ recent launch of a notional $2.5 billion worth of 100-year bonds has been viewed as evidence that investors,...
Read MoreRising greenhouse gas emissions are often talked about as a one-time, irreversible natural experiment with the climate...
Read MoreFirst appeared in BusinessGreen Through our pioneering “Carbon Bubble” work we used a simple idea and easy numbers to...
Read MoreFirst appeared in BusinessGreen As the world’s top financiers gather in Paris ahead of International Climate Finance Day on...
Read MoreFirst appeared in BusinessGreen Ahead of the Paris climate talks the burning question for policy makers and investors is how...
Read MoreThe steep fall in the price of oil since the middle of last year has brought volatility back to the market with a vengeance,...
Read MoreOver the past 18 months the Carbon Tracker Initiative has written a number of studies on the economics of the controversial...
Read MoreCarbon Tracker Initiative's Anthony Hobley argues that far from being a disaster for clean tech, low oil prices could aid...
Read MoreCarbon Tracker comment on US-China climate change agreement “For Carbon Tracker, today’s announcement of the “joint...
Read MoreCarbon Tracker’s ultimate vision is a climate-secure energy and financial system. This does not mean fossil fuels being...
Read More