Opinion: Liberalisation and decarbonisation are a recipe for volatility
Energy transition
Seb Kennedy
03 February 2022
Market-based pricing for gas saved EU consumers billions – until this winter’s energy crunch came along. Europe’s exposure to fossil fuel volatility will actually increase during the clean energy transition.
*This blog has been reposted with permission from the author & Energy Monitor*
The EU has pioneered energy market liberalisation in the belief that free market competition delivers efficiencies that drive down the cost to consumers. The experiment with market-based pricing for natural gas has paid off: EU retailers and heavy industry saved billions of euros on gas import bills over the past decade, according to market data – but will these savings endure? As the winter energy crunch drags on, the pitfalls of liberalised energy trading are coming to the fore.
In the 1990s, most gas consumed in the UK and Europe was bought and sold under long-term contracts that calculated prices as a percentage of the crude oil price. Oil indexation meant gas prices followed crude market movements and did not reflect gas supply and demand fundamentals. Use of trailing averages (average crude prices over the last three or six months) resulted in relatively smooth price patterns that shielded consumers from wild price swings.
Construction of a pipeline owned by the Russian company Gazprom in Germany. (Photo by Mike Mareen via Shutterstock)
This has been replaced with real-time market pricing for gas that reflects supplies from domestic and international sources, as well as daily, weekly and seasonal variations in gas demand. Liberalisation gave rise to deep and liquid gas trading hubs with futures contracts and financial derivatives allowing market participants to hedge their exposure to gas market fundamentals, and profit from price swings.
By transitioning away from oil indexation and embracing market-based gas prices, Europe saved an estimated $70bn in lower gas import bills cumulatively over the past decade, according to the International Energy Agency (IEA). However, soaring global gas prices in the second half of 2021 erased a big chunk of those savings: European gas hubs soared well above oil indexed gas prices, meaning “EU countries will pay around $30bn more for natural gas in 2021 than if they had stuck with oil-indexation,” the IEA said in October 2021.
This yawning gap allowed long-term contract holders to make a boatload of euros from reselling relatively cheap oil-indexed gas into red-hot spot markets this winter. Both Gazprom and its customers seem to have been complicit in inflating spot prices and profiting from this arbitrage. This is evidenced by Gazprom’s unusually low sales of extra gas via auctions in recent months, as well as German gas importers reselling Russian gas to Poland and Ukraine rather than sending it westward to relieve the overheated EU gas market in the final days of 2021.
A frenzy of speculative trading has been blamed for aggravating extreme price swings that swept across the continent after a sudden tightness gripped global gas markets last summer. Spot and futures prices have yo-yoed from record highs to steep intra-day falls and back. The month-ahead gas price on the Dutch Title Transfer Facility, the European gas pricing benchmark, breached €180 per megawatt hour on 21 December 2021, then plunged around 60% over the subsequent ten trading days, before rising by another 50% in the first four days of 2022.
Prices have responded to a raft of international supply-side constraints and curveballs relating to Gazprom’s European supply strategy, as well as hugely variable gas demand amid unpredictable weather, reduced holiday activity and bursts of strong wind power generation between prolonged periods of stillness. Perilously low gas storage levels kept market sentiment jittery.
Ups and downs
Access to global gas prices has given EU importers vital leverage in price negotiations with Gazprom, hence the savings cited by the IEA. The challenge for Europe is that liberalised markets are more volatile and pass that volatility through to consumers much more quickly – and decarbonisation, like any profound system change, stokes further volatility.
Reliance on gas to balance variable wind output means two things: more volatile EU demand for gas, and greater reliance on the ‘marginal molecule’ – i.e. the most expensive gas available at any given moment – to clear the market.
This is compounded by the EU’s use of the ‘pay-as-clear’ model to set power prices, whereby the marginal power source (typically gas) sets the clearing price for all generators, including wind and solar – sources with no fuel costs. Marginal power pricing prevents consumers from benefitting from ‘cheap’ renewables, and means low-cost green generators benefit enormously from expensive gas prices.
Perhaps counter-intuitively, Europe’s exposure to fossil fuel volatility will actually increase during the clean energy transition. The end destination of a carbon-free energy sector might reduce or ultimately sever the link between messy global oil, gas and coal commodity markets and wholesale EU energy prices, but the path to get there will be a roller coaster.
From feast to famine
There are other reasons to question whether market-based gas pricing will be cheaper than oil indexation. Europe is and will always be the market of last resort for LNG. When there is a glut, as occurred in 2020 following the pandemic-induced collapse in energy demand, excess LNG cargoes flooded into Europe and consumers enjoyed very cheap gas. However, in times of scarcity, as we are currently seeing, the opposite occurs: state-owned Asian gas buyers outbid European rivals for LNG until their demand is met, and EU consumers pay a huge winter heating premium.
The savings of liberalisation are predicated on there being a structural surplus in global gas markets. Recent and ongoing events seem to mark the spectacular end of a five-year LNG glut. More supplies will eventually come on stream, but natural gas super-cycles don’t turn on a dime. Some analysts are now warning there might be no real relief from expensive gas until the mid-2020s, when the next wave of US LNG export projects comes on stream.
Ultimately, Europe is wedded to liberalised markets and there is no turning back the clock to the 1990s. The European Commission does not want to revisit its energy market design and said as much in its Autumn communique on the ‘toolbox’ to fight the energy crunch.
This leaves UK and EU wholesale gas and electricity prices exposed to the vagaries of global macroeconomics, the severity of winter in Europe and Asia, upstream investment in gas and LNG projects, and myriad other variables. Consumers will benefit in times of abundance but suffer greatly when feast turns to famine. Whether this turns out to be cheaper than the counterfactual is academic, as no realistic alternative exists. One thing is certain, however: it is going to be a rocky ride.
Seb Kennedy is the founding editor of Energy Flux, an independent newsletter all about the energy transition (www.EnergyFlux.news). Seb has written about energy markets since 2008 for a variety of industry publications and energy consultancies.
Never miss a word with updates directly to your inbox
Keep up to date with the latest news and reports as they are released.
This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.
Essential Cookies (always enabled)
Essential cookies are required in order to view this website and save your cookie preferences.
If you disable this cookie, we will not be able to save your preferences. This means that every time you visit this website you will need to enable or disable cookies again.
Show details
Name
Provider
Purpose
Expiration
_GRECAPTCHA
www.google.com
This cookie is set by the Google recaptcha service to identify bots to protect the website against malicious spam attacks.
5 months 27 days
Analytics Cookies
This website uses Google Analytics to collect anonymous information such as the number of visitors to the site, and the most popular pages.
Keeping this cookie enabled helps us to improve our website.
Please enable Strictly Necessary Cookies first so that we can save your preferences!
Show details
Name
Provider
Purpose
Expiration
_ga_*
carbontracker.org
Google Analytics sets this cookie to store and count page views.
year 1 month 4 days
_ga
carbontracker.org
The _ga cookie, installed by Google Analytics, calculates visitor, session and campaign data and also keeps track of site usage for the site's analytics report. The cookie stores information anonymously and assigns a randomly generated number to recognize unique visitors.
1 year 1 month 4 days
_gid
carbontracker.org
Installed by Google Analytics, _gid cookie stores information on how visitors use a website, while also creating an analytics report of the website's performance. Some of the data that are collected include the number of visitors, their source, and the pages they visit anonymously.
1 day
_gat_gtag_UA_*
carbontracker.org
Google Analytics sets this cookie to store a unique user ID.
1 minute
_gat_UA-*
carbontracker.org
Google Analytics sets this cookie for user behaviour tracking.
1 minute
AnalyticsSyncHistory
linkedin.com
Linkedin set this cookie to store information about the time a sync took place with the lms_analytics cookie.
1 month
__gads
carbontracker.org
The __gads cookie, set by Google, is stored under DoubleClick domain and tracks the number of times users see an advert, measures the success of the campaign and calculates its revenue. This cookie can only be read from the domain they are set on and will not track any data while browsing through other sites.
1 year 24 days
ln_or
carbontracker.org
Linkedin sets this cookie to registers statistical data on users' behaviour on the website for internal analytics.
1 day
Other Cookies
This website uses the following additional cookies:
(List the cookies that you are using on the website here.)
Please enable Strictly Necessary Cookies first so that we can save your preferences!
Show details
Name
Provider
Purpose
Expiration
li_gc
LinkedIn
Linkedin set this cookie for storing visitor's consent regarding using cookies for non-essential purposes.
5 months 27 days
bscookie
LinkedIn
LinkedIn sets this cookie to store performed actions on the website.
1 year
__gpi
Google
Google Ads Service uses this cookie to collect information about from multiple websites for retargeting ads.
1 year 24 days
personalization_id
Twitter
Twitter sets this cookie to integrate and share features for social media and also store information about how the user uses the website, for tracking and targeting.
1 year 1 month 4 days
muc_ads
Twitter
Twitter set this cookie to collect visitor navigation data to optimise ad relevance.
1 year 1 month 4 days
lidc
LinkedIn
LinkedIn sets the lidc cookie to facilitate data center selection.
1 day
bcookie
LinkedIn
LinkedIn sets this cookie from LinkedIn share buttons and ad tags to recognize browser ID.
1 year
UserMatchHistory
LinkedIn
LinkedIn sets this cookie for LinkedIn Ads ID syncing.
1 month
test_cookie
doubleclick.net
The test_cookie is set by doubleclick.net and is used to determine if the user's browser supports cookies.
15 mins
YSC
YouTube
This cookie is set by YouTube to track views of embedded videos.
Session
VISITOR_INFO1_LIVE
YouTube
This cookie is set by Youtube to keep track of user preferences for Youtube videos embedded in sites;it can also determine whether the website visitor is using the new or old version of the Youtube interface.